For many people, Thanksgiving dinner is all about the dessert that comes after. Most families serve the tried and true classics – Pumpkin Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, or both! Whether you’re looking for something unique to serve up this year or you’re simply tired of these Thanksgiving dessert staples, Tiffany’s Bakery can help. Discover some of our favorite alternative Thanksgiving desserts.

Half Dozen Halloween Pumpkin Cupcakes

Pumpkin Cupcakes. While a traditional pumpkin pie can grow tired, these adorable Pumpkin Cupcakes allow you to embrace the holiday season without the pumpkin flavor. Made with yellow cake and topped with vanilla buttercream icing and crystalized sugar, these treats are sure to delight your holiday guests. They’re a great handheld snack for the kids, who may not have developed a palette for the more refined desserts served during the holidays.

Carrot Cake. Cake is always a great substitute for pumpkin pie. Our Carrot Cake gives you hints of the holiday spices you would find in a traditional Thanksgiving dessert like nutmeg and cinnamon. Layered with our delectable cream cheese icing, this cake is sure to be a hit amongst your guests. We have a variety of sizes available, so whether you’re having 6 guests or the entire family over for dinner, you’re covered.

Caramel Apple Walnut Pie. If you prefer pie but simply don’t want pumpkin, our Caramel Apple Walnut Pie is a great substitute! It’s the perfect combination of sweet and savory, with just the right balance of that warm, nutty walnut flavor. Serve this as-is after your hearty Thanksgiving meal or warm it in the oven for a few minutes to create an ooey-gooey delight.

Jumbo Heathbar Crunch Cookie

Jumbo Heath Bar Crunch Cookie. Toffee is a sweet and crunchy holiday favorite, which we’ve taken and jam-packed into our delicious jumbo cookies! Welcome our twist on toffee brittle into your home this holiday season with an order of our Heath Bar Crunch Cookies. We also offer our jumbo cookies in a variety of other flavors, making it easy to find something that will please everyone in your crowd. Grab a few to create a cookie platter for your Thanksgiving dessert spread.

Thanksgiving is almost here! Stop by Tiffany's Bakery for all of your holiday desserts this year, or have them delivered for the ultimate convenience.